If you haven’t yet read the critiques of Rosanne Simunovic, I highly recommend perusing through them.

http://masterclasslady.com/2008/03/20/top-11-american-idol-season-7-vocal-masterclass-article-the-lennon-mccartney-songbook-part-two/#da

Follow me over the break for more…….

“DAVID ARCHULETA: THE LONG AND WINDING ROAD”

Strengths:David A. – this is one of my favourite songs from the Beatles. This song has such a beautiful lyric and melody and I thought that the sensitive and poignant lyrics and soaring melody line complimented your prodigious vocal instrument and genuine personality.

This was an absolutely stellar performance. The feeling and the emotion behind your singing were palpable. It was just one of those spellbinding musical moments that are truly special and I just marvelled at the depth and maturity of your talent.

As in many previous performances, you treated the listeners to a vocal showcase that emphasized everything that is so important and correct in solid technical skills. The forward momentum, the beautiful and heartfelt phrasing, sustained vocal quality on the pure vowels, the open and expressive facial features – need I say more?

Yes, one more thing, the soulful bending of the melodic line was creatively superb and not overdone. You bring such discipline and intelligence to this competition, given your young age, and you are a fighter. I love this!

I had goose bumps and, as Simon said, it was a“Masterclass” - so there you go!

Congratulations and bravo, young David! Just excellent!

Critique:David – this poignant showcase, emphasizing the strength of your performing and vocal ability left you – and me – critique-free!

You are back on the horse, young man. Giddy ‘yup!

Bravo once again!”

Thank you for your critique, Rosanne!